Understanding Backtracking Patterns: Sequential vs Choice Generation

Many struggle with backtracking because they confuse two fundamental patterns i.e Sequential Decision Making and Choice Generation.

The Conversion Funnel: From Problem to Pattern

📝 PROBLEM STATEMENT
        ↓
🤔 INITIAL ANALYSIS
        ↓
🎯 PATTERN RECOGNITION
        ↓
⚡ ALGORITHM SELECTION
        ↓
🔧 IMPLEMENTATION CHOICE

1. 🎯 Sequential Decision Making

1. Must process elements in order
2. Make decisions at each step
3. Examples: N-Queens, Path finding, Game levels

Key characteristics:

1. No loops in backtrack function
2. Process level 0 → 1 → 2 → etc.
3. Each step is a decision point

Example: Game with armor usage

function backtrack(level, health, armorUsed) {
  if (level === damage.length) return; // base case
  
  // Decision 1: Don't use armor
  backtrack(level + 1, health + damage[level], armorUsed);
  
  // Decision 2: Use armor (if available)
  if (!armorUsed) {
    backtrack(level + 1, health + reducedDamage, true);
  }
}

2. 🔄 Choice Generation Pattern

1. Generate combinations/subsets
2. Order doesn't matter
3. Examples: Subsets, Combinations, Permutations

Key characteristics:

1. Uses loops in backtrack function
2. Can process elements in any order
3. Focus on "which items" to include

Example: All subsets

function backtrack(start, path) {
  results.push([...path]);
  
  for (let i = start; i < nums.length; i++) {
    path.push(nums[i]);
    backtrack(i + 1, path);
    path.pop();
  }
}

3. Key Difference Visualized

Sequential (N-Queens):

Row 0: Place Q in col 0,1,2,3
  ↓
Row 1: Place Q in safe cols
  ↓
Row 2: ...

Choice (Subsets):

Include 1? Yes/No
  ↓       ↓
Include 2?  Include 2?
  ↓  ↓      ↓  ↓
... ...    ... ...

4. Common Mistakes

1. ❌ Using loops for sequential problems
2. ❌ Trying to generate combinations when order matters
3. ✅ Correct: Direct recursion for sequential, loops for combinations

Remember:

• Ordered problems → sequential pattern
• Unordered combinations → choice generation

5. Practical Examples:

1. N-Queens, Game levels, Path sum → Sequential
2. Subsets, Combinations → Choice generation

The core difference is whether you must process elements in order (sequential) or can choose any remaining element (choice generation).

6. Final Tip:

When solving a problem, ask:

1. Must I process elements in order?
2. Is this about making sequential decisions or generating combinations?

This will guide you to the correct pattern!

Hope this thread helps clarify backtracking patterns!

These two patterns cover 90% of backtracking problems. Master them first, then explore hybrids!

Backtracking  
├── Sequential (Ordered)  
│  ├── N-Queens  
│  ├── Game Levels  
│  └── Pathfinding  
└── Choice Generation (Unordered)  
  ├── Subsets  
  ├── Combinations  
  └── Permutations* (*order-sensitive but still choice-based)  

#100Devs #LeetCode #Algorithms #Programming